Is the Emissions Trading Scheme really saving the Planet ?
Sky photo created by rawpixel.com
www.freepik.com
Example
For example, take these fictitious companies -Green-Cars : produces electric cars using processes that produce a lot of waste and a lot of emissions. It has a credit because it is producing electric cars. Therefore it doesn't matter how much pollution Green-Cars generates, it has a surplus.
Red-Plastics : produces plastics. This is a filthy process and it is producing a non-Green product. It has a carbon deficit. Actually it doesn't matter how efficiently it is producing plastics, it will still be in deficit.
Red-Plastics buys carbon-credits from Green-Cars. Green-Cars gets money and Red-Plastics is now Carbon-Neutral and is now a Green company.Tesla
Would it surprise you to know that Tesla has made a loss since it started until 2020. Its first year in profit was made by selling its carbon credits ?Carbon Neutral ?
Back to the example. Green-Cars is still producing pollution, it was never really Green anyway. And it hasn't changed any of its practices and it doesn't need to change any of its practices. Red-Plastics is still producing all the horrible pollution and it is producing a non-Green product. But it is now Carbon Neutral.
Yay, we have saved the planet. NOT !!! This is the kind of idiocy that is supposed to save our planet.
Conclusion
Luckily, I believe that the threat may be fictitious, so it doesn't matter much. The zealots are lying so much that I am unable to determine if the crisis is real.- Above are my views based on my personal experience and my interactions with leading scientists and real-life observers of events.
- If you spot any errors in fact or deduction, please send me a note so that I can correct this piece.
- If you have an opposing viewpoint, let me know with facts or even reasoned arguments and I will update this essay.
- How do you tell the difference between a believer in science and a believer in religion.
References
- How Al Gore built the global warming fraud - And changed the alarmism from global cooling to global warming, and now climate change.
- Kyoto Protocol - Britannica. Al Gore, as US Vice-President, opened the 1997 Kyoto conference that created emissions trading.
- About the NZ ETS - Environmental Protection Authority. One unit = one tonne of CO2, obligations placed upstream, units earned by forestry.
- Agriculture removed from the ETS - Ministry for the Environment (Nov 2024). NZ's biggest emitting sector sits outside the scheme.
- Tesla's profits are not from selling cars. 2020 net income US$721m, regulatory credit sales US$1.58bn.
- Tesla regulatory credit revenue by year. About US$9bn since 2009.
- More than 90% of Verra rainforest carbon offsets are worthless - Guardian / Die Zeit / SourceMaterial investigation (Jan 2023).
- Industry pocketed over €24 billion in windfall profits from free EU ETS allowances, 2008-2014 - Carbon Market Watch.
- The EU's own claim that the ETS has cut covered-sector emissions by 50% since 2005 - European Commission (Apr 2025).
